Defects disputes can arise during the works, at practical completion or considerably later. The initial response often has a significant bearing on the parties’ ability to determine responsibility and quantify any resulting loss.
The contractual documents should be considered first. The allegation may relate to workmanship, materials, compliance with the specification or design responsibility, and each raises a different enquiry.
Where the issue is technically significant, an inspection and expert assessment may be required before remedial work begins. Photographs, testing records, drawings, specifications and site records should be preserved, particularly where the original work is about to be opened up, removed or replaced.
Remediation does not necessarily determine liability
On a live project, there may be sound reasons to carry out remedial works promptly without first resolving every issue of liability. The parties can sometimes agree a process for inspection and remediation while expressly reserving their positions on responsibility and cost.
The contractor’s own right to return and remedy should also be kept in view. Where the contract gives the contractor an opportunity to rectify during the rectification period, an employer that engages a third party without offering that opportunity may find its recoverable damages limited to what the remedial work would have cost the original contractor: see Pearce & High Ltd v Baxter [1999] BLR 101.
Where residential work is involved, statutory duties may also need to be considered. Section 1 of the Defective Premises Act 1972 imposes duties in connection with work undertaken in the provision of a dwelling. The Building Safety Act 2022 materially extended the limitation periods applicable to claims under the 1972 Act and introduced further duties relating to work on buildings containing dwellings.
The Supreme Court returned to this territory in URS Corporation Ltd v BDW Trading Ltd [2025] UKSC 21, which addressed the retrospective effect of the extended limitation period, the recoverability of the cost of remedial works carried out voluntarily, and the availability of contribution between parties responsible for the same damage. The decision has widened the range of parties who may find themselves defending historic defects claims, and any limitation analysis should now start there.
Those statutory claims sit alongside contractual rights and obligations and can become important in disputes involving historic defects or residential developments.
The immediate priority in any defects dispute should therefore be to establish the technical and contractual position without compromising the available evidence. Remediation may be necessary, but it should be undertaken with a clear understanding of the implications for any subsequent claim.
Accurate at the time of writing. This information is provided for general information purposes only and should not be relied upon as legal advice.






