Practical completion is a familiar expression in construction contracts, but its legal significance is greater than the relatively simple certificate that records it.
Under JCT contracts, practical completion can affect the operation of liquidated damages, release of retention, the transfer of risk and insurance responsibility for the works, the commencement of the rectification period and a number of related contractual obligations.
The difficulty is that practical completion is generally not exhaustively defined.
The Court of Appeal considered the issue in Mears Ltd v Costplan Services South East Ltd [2019] EWCA Civ 502. The Court confirmed that practical completion is a matter of fact and degree and that the works need not conform with the contract in every respect. Patent defects or outstanding items may be compatible with practical completion where they are properly regarded as trifling, assessed in the context of the purpose for which the works are intended.
The Court also rejected the argument that, because the contract treated a particular departure from the specification as a material and substantial breach, practical completion could not be certified. A breach of contract and a defect that prevents practical completion are not the same thing, and drafting that labels a breach as material does not by itself answer the practical completion question.
A snagging list does not determine the issue by itself
The number of outstanding items can therefore be less significant than their nature.
A relatively short list containing one substantial defect may prevent practical completion, while a longer list of genuinely minor items may not. The certifier must consider the works as a whole and the effect of the outstanding items on their intended use.
The decision in Mears also confirmed that the fact that a defect cannot economically be remedied does not determine whether practical completion has occurred. The relevant question remains whether the defect is more than trifling.
Contractors should consequently review the completion requirements well before the final inspection. Commissioning, outstanding documentation, approvals and unresolved defects should all form part of that preparation.
For employers and certifiers, refusal to certify practical completion should similarly be grounded in the contract and the actual condition of the works.
Practical completion is therefore not simply an administrative milestone. It is a contractual event with immediate commercial consequences, and disputes over certification should be approached accordingly.
Accurate at the time of writing. This information is provided for general information purposes only and should not be relied upon as legal advice.






